Today’s essential question: How do we successfully critique art?
Today we will:
- further our understanding of how to critique art by completing the following tasks:
- post thoughtful comments to 3-5 art projects
- pick one artwork to critique in greater depth
- fill out a graphic organizer to guide our critique of that artwork
- use our notes from the graphic organizer to create a blog post of at least 150 words critiquing the artwork
- respond to classmates’ Post It Note comments (if time allows)
Art Critique Blog Post Guidelines
- at least 150 words
- includes several strong comments that refers to the artist’s use of art elements and principles
- cites evidence (if you write that a piece contains successfully shading, explain how the artist has created that shading)
- demonstrates proper use of the English language
- published to student blog by 11:00.
Sample Art Critique
(My example is 306 words. You only need to write 150, but can go longer if you feel inspired like I was.)
In the drawing of Drake made of Drake lyrics, the artist created realistic value using black ink, but instead of using traditional ink shading techniques such as hatching or stippling, he layered words on top of one another. The more he layered words in an area, the darker the value he created. The focal point of the artwork is the eye area. We naturally look towards eyes, and in this artwork, the eyes are located about a third of the way from the top of the page, further drawing attention to the face. The way that Drake is gazing at the viewer, combined with the words, “Never give up,” make it feel like Drake is offering encouragement directly to the viewer. This makes the artwork feel hopeful and intimate. The best parts of the drawing are the visible tear lines. They add texture and allude to the story behind the artwork. The artist nearly gave up on the piece, and in a moment of frustration, ripped the artwork into small pieces. Two friends convinced him to tape it back together and finish it, and one even helped him iron it. The rip marks, combined with the words, “Never give up,” add a new layer of meaning to the piece. This artwork reminds me of one of my proudest moments in my teaching career. I had tried several times, unsuccessfully, to convince the artist to continue working on the project, but I had never thought to suggest ironing it. It was heartwarming watching my students work together to put the piece back together. I learn from my students each day, and this artwork is an especially powerful reminder of one of those times. If given the option, I would definitely buy this drawing, both for the level of technical skill it displays and for its conceptual sophistication.